Top Life Alert Alternatives – Best Medical Alert Systems To Consider

Years ago, Life Alert popularized the concept of medical alert monitoring services to the general public with their “I’ve fallen and I can’t get up!®” advertising. Besides Life Alert, there are numerous companies that provide medical alert products and services in the US. In this post, we will list various top Life Alert alternatives for you or your parents to compare and look into.

In-Home Medical Alert Systems With Monitoring

Standard in-home medical alert systems do what Life Alert’s standard in-home system does. They come with a base console unit and panic button that is usually worn around the neck. When an emergency happens, the user will press their panic button for help. This sends a call to a monitoring center through the base console unit. A representative will answer the call and speak with the elderly user to offer assistance.

Standard console units will connect through a home phone line like a traditional landline, and most VoIP or Cable phone lines. Newer cellular console units are also widely available. Those come with their own cellular network connection so users do not need to have their own phone line.

The main advantage of choosing these alternative companies compared to Life Alert is that they do not require multi-year contracts to get started. Most will let you pay month-to-month and cancel at will. This translates into less hassle if things change and you need to cancel.

Most of these medical alert companies offer competitive prices starting at $29.95 a month and do not require a separate start-up fee.


An example of a Life Alert alternative is LifeStation. LifeStation is a large and respected medical alert company with 40 years of industry experience. They operate their own US-based monitoring center that meets high industry standards. The company also offers a full range of products options, from standard in-home systems, to fall detection and GPS systems. To learn more, check out our LifeStation review.

Medical Guardian

Another worthwhile company to consider is Medical Guardian. Medical Guardian is the leader amongst a newer generation of medical alert companies that is bringing to the market both standard medical alert systems and newer monitoring technologies to help seniors live independently in their own homes. To learn more, check out our Medical Guardian review.

For more medical alert companies to compare with, check out our Medical Alert Systems Reviews section and Comparison Chart.

Medical Alert Systems With Fall Detection

Bay Alarm Medical Fall Detection button

Bay Alarm Medical Fall Detection button

In-home medical alert systems work well for most customers, but some prefer the added protection of fall detection. Medical alert systems with fall detection are able to detect if the senior user has fallen and automatically place an alert call. In order to detect a fall, the system incorporates sensors into the necklace pendant.

This is especially helpful for seniors or other customers who are at higher risk of falling, fainting or experiencing sudden medical episodes that render them incapacitated. They may have difficulties or are completely unable to voluntarily press their panic button for help. Life Alert does not offer the fall detection, but fortunately there are other medical alert companies that do offer it.

If you can interested, check out LifeStation, Medical Guardian or Bay Alarm Medical for more information. These companies provide fall detection options with their various systems, including standard phone line, cellular “no phone line needed“, and selectively, their mobile medical alert systems.

Medical Alert Systems with GPS

Premium Guardian

Premium Guardian with GPS

With the rise of GPS locations tracking technology, more and more seniors and their families have been looking into mobile medical alert systems that are not tethered to their homes. Life Alert offers its own version as well. These medical alert systems come with GPS trackers that will relay the unit’s location to the monitoring center. That provides an additional source of information to the monitoring center to ascertain where to deploy emergency help to (if it’s needed).

In comparison, in-home systems are registered to a stationary physical address. If alert calls come into a call center, the basic assumption is that the senior is at his or her home, and if need be, that is where help will be dispatched to. Some consumers deliberately shop for a medical alert system with long range, so that it works even when they are out and about. What they really need is a mobile medical alert system with GPS. There are no range restrictions – the system works wherever there is strong cellular network signals that it can connect to.

Premium Guardian GPS System

Medical alert systems with GPS typically come in the form of a small portable or wearable device. An example of a medical alert system with GPS is the Premium Guardian by Medical Guardian. This is a small water-resistant pendant that can be worn with a neck lanyard. It can be used both at home and out of the home.

Premium Guardian comes with its own speaker and microphone, so seniors and other customers can speak directly into it for help. Premium Guardian also offers fall detection as an add-on feature. To learn more, check out our Medical Guardian Mobile Alert System With GPS Review

Bay Alarm Medical GPS Mobile Alert System

Another option is the Bay Alarm Medical mobile medical alert with GPS. Like the Premium Guardian, it is a small pendant that comes with its own speaker and microphone. What distinguishes the Bay Alarm Medical GPS system for other systems is that it offers Caregiver Tracking. This is a password-secured online portal that will share the senior user’s GPS information with authorized caregivers and family members.

Elderly patients of dementia or Alzheimer’s disease are vulnerable to losing their direction and getting lost. Caregiver Tracking allows the elderly patient’s caregivers and family members to quickly locate them when the situation calls for it. To learn more, check out our Bay Alarm Medical GPS Mobile Alert System Review

For more choices, check out our Mobile Medical Alert Systems with GPS Reviews section.

Medical Alert Systems With No Monthly Fee

Freedom Alert 35911 System

Freedom Alert No Monthly Fee System

For seniors on a budget, medical alert systems with no monthly fees are viable alternatives to Life Alert or similar subscription-based systems. The main reason that it comes without a monthly fee is that there is no live monitoring access for users. Emergency calls are routed directly to the senior’s emergency contacts and/or 911.

Freedom Alert

As popular No Monthly Fee system is the Freedom Alert. It comes with a base console unit and a speakerphone pendant with a panic alert button. Similar to Life Alert, the user can press on their panic button if an emergency occurs. The system is designed to auto-dial up to 4 emergency contacts and then 911.

The manufacturer also produces another no monthly fee system called the Guardian Alert. The Guardian Alert calls only 911 and will not auto-dial emergency contacts.

The key advantage of no monthly fee systems like the Freedom Alert or Guardian Alert is that there are no continuing subscription fees. There is a one-time fee to purchase equipment. A main disadvantage of such systems is the lack of live support when an emergency actually happens. During emergency situations, a monitored solution ensures that a trained live person is always available to answer the phone and get the senior user help. To compare the pros and cons, check out this Monitored Vs Non-Monitored Medical Alert System Comparison.

Activity Monitoring and Tracking

From time to time, readers inquire about medical alert systems that will monitor in the background for early warning signals of potential issues. Lifefone offers a basic Activity Assurance program that will check in with the senior system user on a daily basis. If mom is not well enough to answer the automated check-in, a monitoring representative will call her directly.

A more advanced system is the Family Guardian system by Medical Guardian. This cutting-edge system consists of an in-home medical alert console unit and satellite motion sensors that can be strategically placed in different areas of mom’s home.

You can customize the alert triggers based on your mom’s daily habitual routine. You can have a “wake and well” alert. When your mom wakes up and starts moving around, the system detects the motion and sends you – and family members and caregiver an alert message to this effect.

There is more information in our post here: Enhanced Medical Alert Tracking Offers Early Signals Of Emergencies

To recap, this post presented the main types of medical alert systems and various companies that are top Life Alert alternatives to consider in the market today. Take time to reflect through the needs of you or your parents, and browse through the links to reviews of the products that are the best fit.

Back to top

Be Sociable, Share!

Leave A Comment...